Tucker had a relationship with actor Ben Reed, with whom she had daughter Presley Tanita and son Beau “Grayson”. Tucker has had a relationship with Jerry Laseter, a Nashville musician.
They were engaged for the first time in 1997 and again in 1999. Just days before their 1999 wedding, Tucker canceled the ceremony when she discovered she was pregnant with her third child, Laseter’s daughter Layla LaCosta.