Peterson has been in multiple relationships in his love life. First, he fell in love with Michelle Paige whom he began dating her in college, but later broke up with her.
Nonetheless, he married Michelle in 1992, and two years down the line, the duo had a son name Alex. Dave and Paige had difficulties in theiy marriage, and this resulted to divorce that was finalized in July 2014.
Well, he also dated one of his staff member by the name Pamela Bane for two years from 2012 to 2014. He was also link to wife of the founder of Angels, radio talk show host Curtis Sliwa.