Godderz was first seen wrestling in 2010 at the promotion WFX Wrestling, based in Canada. He appeared on their weekly TV program “WFX Overload”. Godderz was first introduced by Johnny Fairplay on an episode of “WFX Overload”.
In 2011, Godderz signed a contract with professional wrestling promotion Total Nonstop Action Wrestling (TNA) and was sent down to their developmental territory, Ohio Valley Wrestling (OVW) for further training.
On January 11, 2012, Godderz and Marcus Anthony defeated Johnny Spade and Shiloh Jonze to win the OVW Southern Tag Team Championship but lost them 7 days later in a rematch with Spade and Jonze.
On February 22, 2012, Godderz, Rob Terry and Rudy Switchblade defeated Jason Wayne and Shiloh Jonze in a handicap match to win the Southern Tag Team Championship. The team’s reign ended on April 7, when Godderz and Rudy Switchblade, who was also recognized as champion under “The Family Rule”, were defeated by Anarquia and Raul LaMotta.
On April 11, 2012, Godderz and Switchblade defeated Anarquia and Raul LaMotta in a rematch for the Southern Tag Team Championship.
OVW Board of Directors member, Ken Wayne, stripped the titles away from Godderz and Switchblade on June 20, 2012. This was after referee Chris Sharpe allowed them to cheat to win the titles causing the titles to be vacated.
On July 7, 2012, Godderz and Rudy Switchblade defeated Paredyse and Brandon Espinosa in a ladder match to win the vacant Southern Tag Team Championship for the fourth time.
Tara’s Hollywood boyfriend
On December 1, 2012, Godderz and Switchblade were defeated by Alex Silva and Sam Shaw for the Southern Tag Team Championship.
On October 14, 2012, at Bound for Glory, Godderz made his Impact debut on the main roster as Tara’s “Hollywood boyfriend”. Godderz billed simply as “Jesse”, made his in-ring debut on the November 1 episode of Impact Wrestling, defeating ODB in an intergender match, following interference from Tara.
On the November 8 episode of Impact, Jesse teamed up with Tara in a losing effort to ODB in an intergender handicap match. After the match they attacked ODB. Jesse made his pay-per-view debut three days later at Turning Point, teaming with Tara in a losing effort to ODB and Eric Young.
On the following episode of Impact Wrestling, Jesse defeated Young in a singles match. The following week, Jesse was pinned by Young in a three-way match, which also included Robbie E and forced Jesse to wear a turkey suit as part of the Thanksgiving theme.
Jessie Godderz, main evented Impact Wrestling for the first time on December 13, losing to Bully Ray despite outside interference from Tara. During the next two months, Godderz interfered in Tara’s matches, especially ones relating to her title.
After interfering in Tara’s title match with Velvet Sky, Sky gained vengeance on the couple by teaming with James Storm on January 31, 2013, episode of Impact Wrestling to defeat them in a mix tag team match. The following week, Godderz was defeated by Storm in a singles match.
Impact wrestling
On March 22, 2016, episode of Impact Wrestling, Godderz reunited with Robbie E to face Beer Money, Inc. for the Impact World Tag Team Championships, but were unsuccessful in winning the titles, thus turning face for the first time in his career.
The March 29, 2016, episode of Impact Wrestling, Godderz and Robbie E defeated Eric Young and Bram. On June 9, 2017, Godderz confirmed his departure from Impact Wrestling.
Jessie Godderz teamed with fellow Big Brother contestant Austin Matelson on November 9, 2017, under the team name Team Big Brother, they defeated HATE (Peter Avalon and Ray Rosas) in a match for Bar Wrestling.
The Big Brother professional wrestler made his Lucha Underground debut with a Special Guest Appearance as Mr. PEC-Tacular, taking part in the Aztec Warfare match on the Season 4 premiere of Lucha Underground.
On April 24, 2019, Godderz won the OVW Television Championship. However, his reign did not last long, Jessie Godderz lost the championship at OVW’s Run the Ropes on April 26, 2019, to Drew Hernandez, only having the title for two days.
